Sault Ste. Marie police have charged 39-year-old Tyler Kennedy with making alleged threats against Mayor Matthew Shoemaker. The investigation follows reports of online harassment and physical intimidation of the city's leader.

Advertisement

A pattern of volatility preceding the August 21 nomination deadline

Tyler Kennedy’s interest in the upcoming municipal elections appears to have been driven by a desire for attention rather than a commitment to public service. According to a report from SooToday,Kennedy previously indicated he was considering a run for mayor or a Ward 2 council seat primarily to attract publicity and influence the outcome of the vote. This admission is particularly striking given that the nomination deadline for the October 26 elections is August 21.

The upcoming election cycle in Sault Ste. Marie is extensive, covering contests for mayor, city council seats in Wards 1 through 5, and various positions on the Algoma District School Board and the Sault Ste. Marie Social Services Administration Board. Kennedy's stated intent to enter the race came before his current legal complications, but the window for filing nominations is rapidly closing.

From Tim Hortons assaults to threats against Sault police

The current allegations against Kennedy follow a series of recent legal confrontations involving violent or threatening behavior. As reported by SooToday, Kennedy was convicted in July 2024 for posting a message in a Facebook group that threatened the death of a Sault Ste. Marie police officer. In that instance, he reportedly offered donations to local organizations if the officer died.

This follows a prior conviction for assault with a weapon, where he allegedly struck a man with an iron sand wedge at a Bay Street Tim Hortons. During that sentencing, the judge noted Kennedy's lengthy criminal record and several violent offenses.. While Kennedy has since completed an anger-management program, his history of breaches of probation remains a significant factor in his current legal standing.

The July 24 investigation into digital and physical intimidation

The Sault Ste. Marie Police Service initiated an investigation on July 24 after online moderators at Village Media intercepted a comment that appeared to threaten an individual . This intervention by the moderators of SooToday prompted the police to look into the matter further. Investigators allege that Kennedy did not limit his actions to the digital realm; they claim he distributed threatening material through public online platforms and later attended a location frequently visited by Mayor Matthew Shoemaker in an attempt to intimidate him.

Kennedy was subsequently arrested on August 13 while walking on Pilgrim Street. while the police release did not explicitly name the victim, the circumstances described in the report strongly relate to the mayor.

Will the August 20 court date resolve Kennedy's eligibility?

Several critcal questions remain regarding Kennedy’s future and his potential involvement in the upcoming municipal and school board elections. While the charges are unproven and Kennedy is presumed innocent, it is unclear how his bail requirements and the need for a surety will impact his ability to participate in civic life. Furthermore, the specific content of the alleged online threats has not been fully disclosed to the public, leaving the exact nature of the intimidation against the mayor unverified.

The court's decision on August 20 will be a pivotal moment in determining whether Kennedy's legal circumstances allow him to pursue any remaining political ambitions before the nomination window closes on August 21.