Following the sentencing of former NYPD Sergeant Erik Duran to prison for the death of a fleeing suspect, his defense attorney has reported a significant outpouring of public and political support. Duran was convicted of manslaughter in February after a bench trial concerning the death of Eric Duprey.

Widespread Public and Political Support

Duran's attorney, Arthur Aidala, described the community's reaction as a rare and remarkable experience for a criminal defense attorney. Many individuals have contacted Aidala to express their dissatisfaction with the verdict and sentence, offering assistance to Sgt. Duran.

Details of the Incident

The incident occurred when Eric Duprey, while operating a motorized scooter, evaded a drug sting operation and moved towards civilians and police officers. According to the defense, Duran threw a bystander's cooler at Duprey in an attempt to stop him. The defense argued that Duprey's speed, estimated near 30 mph, posed a severe risk of injury or death to pedestrians.

Expert Testimony and Gang Association

A defense expert testified during the trial, supporting the claim that Duran's action was intended to protect others. Supporters also pointed to Duprey's alleged ties to the Trinitarios gang, known for violent incidents in the Bronx.

Sentencing and Gubernatorial Pardon Pledge

Prosecutors had sought a prison sentence of five to fifteen years. Judge Guy Mitchell ultimately sentenced Duran to three to nine years, a decision that drew considerable political attention. Nassau County Executive Bruce Blakeman, a Republican candidate for governor, pledged to pardon Duran if he wins the upcoming election against Governor Kathy Hochul.

Judicial Reasoning and Defense Arguments

Judge Mitchell rejected the defense's argument of self-defense or protection of others, stating the sentence was intended as a 'general deterrent' for other officers. Aidala countered that the ruling could hinder police officers' ability to perform their duties effectively, arguing the incident was not a typical police encounter. Duran stated he did not intend lethal force and used the cooler as an alternative to drawing his firearm.

Appeal and Fundraising Efforts

Duran is currently appealing his conviction, and Aidala has requested his release on bail during the appeals process. Oral arguments for the appeal are expected later this week. The Sergeants Benevolent Association (SBA) of the NYPD reaffirmed its support for Duran. The SBA and the National Police Defense Foundation have launched a fundraising campaign to support Duran's appeal, aiming to overturn the verdict before the November elections.