Penn Badgley is set to lead a new Prime Video series titled Everyone In My Family Has Killed Someone. The actor will portray a mystery writer investigating his own relatives after bodies are discovered at a family home in Vermont.

Advertisement

Ern Cunningham’s Reluctant Return to Rural Vermont

Penn Badgley takes on the role of Ern Cunningham, a mystery writer who returns to his snowy hometown in rural Vermont. According to the report, the reunion is intended to welcome home his brother, Michael, who is being released from prison—a conviction that Ern Cunningham himself helped secure.

The plot thickens when a frozen corpse is discovered, and a brutal snowstorm traps the extended family inside the residence. As reported, the series takes a dark turn as Ern Cunningham realizes that every member of his family is a suspect because, as the title suggests, every person in the household has killed someone.

From Joe Goldberg’s Crimes to Ern Cunningham’s Clues

This move marks a significant shift for Penn Badgley, who recently concluded his run as the charismatic serial killer Joe Goldberg in the series You. While Joe Goldberg spent five seasons committing shocking crimes, the character of Ern Cunningham will be tasked with solving them in a blackly comedic setting.

Badgley's career has often balanced the line between the charming and the sinister, starting with his breakout role as Dan Humphrey in the CW drama Gossip Girl. By pivoting from the predator to the investigator, Penn Badgley is leainng into a "whodunnit" trend that has seen a resurgence in streaming media , moving from the role of the perpetrator to the detective.

Prime Video’s Expanding Slate with Badgley and Meghann Fahy

The partnership between Penn Badgley and Prime Video extends beyond this new mystery.. The streaming platform is also releasing You Deserve Each Other, a romantic comedy starring Penn Badgley and Meghann Fahy.

Additionally,Penn Badgley is slated to appear in the thriller NDA alongside Rachel Zegler. this variety of projects suggests a strategic effort to diversify Badgley's image away from the singular intensity of the You franchise, showcasing his range across comedy, thriller, and mystery genres.

The Missing Release Date for the Cunningham Family Saga

Despite the excitement surrounding the premise, several key details remain unknown.. The report notes that Everyone In My Family Has Killed Someone is currently in development, and no official release date has been announced by Prime Video.

Furthermore, the source does not specify which actors will fill the roles of the other family members, leaving the composition of the "killer family" a mystery. it remains unclear if the series will be a limited event or a multi-season commitment, and the report only provides the perspective of the production's current status without input from the stduio.